Connect with us ! Google+ LinkedIn Pinterest YouTube

Could Eating Chocolate Make You Smarter?

Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedIn23Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest2Email this to someone

In science it is easy to get carried away with over-interpretation of data; one sees flowers where there aren’t any! This serious flaw is highlighted in the recent 2012 edition of the New England eating chocolateJournal of Medicine; Franz Messerli, a well published cardiologist at Columbia University noted a strong correlation between the consumption of dark chocolate and winning the Nobel Prize. Indeed, the author goes on to recommend increased consumption of the dark substance so that cognition is improved in the overall population and more humorously, the chances of winning the Nobel Prize are greatly enhanced.

The author shows a graph of 23 countries along with their chocolate intake, and the number of Nobel Prizes won per ten million people. Countries with the greatest intake show the most Nobel Prizes (Switzerland, Austria, Denmark and Norway) and, where there is the least intake (Japan, China, Greece, Italy, Brazil) the lowest wins of the famed prize.

It is true that dark chocolate is loaded with flavonoids; a large class of compounds abundant in the plant kingdom and associated with improvement of a variety of health issues. Increased consumption of flavonoids and particularly a subclass called flavonols which are present in cocoa, have received increased scrutiny due to their benefits for the cardiovascular system including; lowering blood pressure, improving the health of blood vessels (improving endothelial function), maintaining vessel elasticity. Flavonols are also linked to improving cognition and reducing dementia especially in seniors.

The mechanism of action of flavonols may be due to their antioxidant effects thereby quenching the highly reactive free radicals which are being continually generated in the body. There is also a direct vasodilatory effect on blood vessels.

However, does chocolate deliver sufficient amount of flavonols for clinical efficacy? One would have to consume large quantities of chocolate to achieve any measurable results. Plus, the effects of other ingredients in chocolate including dairy, sugar, emulsifiers, binding agents, fats etc. may have an opposite effect.

However, as Maurage and colleagues report in the recent Journal of Nutrition regarding the conclusions drawn by Messerli, they “go way beyond the data and thus must be questioned on methodological, statistical and logical grounds.”

The first objection is on methodological grounds since the data used an averaged chocolate consumption of each country and NOT the actual consumption by the Nobel Prize winners (I don’t think such data is available). This poses a problem, namely one uses group behaviour to draw conclusions on individual behaviour.

Second, the correlation of chocolate consumption is for 2 years, while the Nobel Prize winners ‘studied’ were chosen from the last 100 years! The two variables/factors aren’t monitored for the same duration. Additionally, who knows what the consumption of chocolate was for the past 100 years.

Third, flavonoids are present in other foods like tea, wine and vegetables and fruits. Shouldn’t the intake of any of these effect the correlation?

Fourth, correlation does not imply causation, it just shows the degree of relationship between the two parameters or factors and no more, no less.

In conclusion, it is tempting to advocate the consumption of chocolate on a national level, but one has to be cautious to consider over-interpretation of such correlations.

What do you think of this theory? Leave a comment in the section below!

Image by © WavebreakmediaMicro via DollarPhotoClub

References

Messerli FH. “Chocolate consumption, cognitive function, and Nobel Laureates”. New Engl. J Med 2012; 367: 1652-1564.

Linthwaite S and Fuller GN. “Milk, chocolate and Nobel Prizes” Pract. Neurol. 2013; 13: 63-67.

Maurage P et-al. “Does Chocolate Consumption really boost Nobel award chances?”. J Nutr. 2013; 143: 931-933.

Gambale R. “Statistics and Medicine; the indispensable know-how of the researcher”. Translational Med 2013; 5; 28-31.

1 Comment

  1. Denise Reply

    Great article, although its such a shame to know chocolate won’t get me a Nobel Prize…I’m always trying to find justification to consume chocolate! Great read 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Retype the CAPTCHA code from the image
Change the CAPTCHA codeSpeak the CAPTCHA code
 

Protected with IP Blacklist CloudIP Blacklist Cloud

JOIN US NOW
Purus sed vel ultricies, lorem rhoncus. Augue hac, adipiscing risus, sed ac? Pid nunc dignissim, non, ac parturient sociis enim.
Your Information will never be shared with any third party.
SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER
All rights reserved © Company Name, 2014
Dolor aliquet augue augue sit magnis, magna aenean aenean et! Et tempor, facilisis cursus turpis tempor odio, cursus montes ac turpis. Ultrices! Massa integer augue ridiculus adipiscing, massa cras pid. Turpis placerat scelerisque, vut odio mus non, mattis porttitor, nunc odio, turpis tortor sit? Pid amet, sed facilisis.
  • Goblinus globalus fantumo tandempo
  • Scelerisque cursus dignissim donus
  • Montes vutario lacus quis arcupolisio
  • Leftomato denitro oculus tepircos den
  • Spiratio dodenus christmas popupius
  • Afrenius globalus spiritum tandempo
  • Fitatos vutario lacus quis arcup delis
Here's $3 Off
Apply $3 off at checkout to any AOR product purchase. Just send your name and email and we'll email you your coupon.
Your Information will never be shared with any third party.
JOIN US NOW
Stay ahead of the curve with the latest AOR news, industry trends, and new product launches.
Your Information will never be shared with any third party.
Do you want massive traffic?
Dignissim enim porta aliquam nisi pellentesque. Pulvinar rhoncus magnis turpis sit odio pid pulvinar mattis integer aliquam!
  • Goblinus globalus fantumo tubus dia montes
  • Scelerisque cursus dignissim lopatico vutario
  • Montes vutario lacus quis preambul den lacus
  • Leftomato denitro oculus softam lorum quis
  • Spiratio dodenus christmas gulleria tix digit
  • Dualo fitemus lacus quis preambul pat turtulis
* we never share your e-mail with third parties.
JOIN US TODAY
For the latest:
AOR is committed to your privacy, your information will not be shared with any third party. You may unsubscribe at any time.
COMPANY UPDATES
INDUSTRY TRENDS
PRODUCT LAUNCHES
Nutrition Education
AOR is committed to your privacy, your information will not be shared with any third party. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Science-based facts from our team of top medical experts delivered right to your inbox!
Health Basics
Fitness Advice
JOIGNEZ-NOUS AUJOURD'HUI
Les dernières nouvelles:
AOR s’engage à protéger la confidentialité de vos données. Elles ne seront pas partagées avec des tiers. Vous pouvez vous désabonner à tout moment
MISE À JOUR
TENDANCES DE L'INDUSTRIE
LANCEMENTS DE PRODUITS
JOIN US TODAY
For the latest:
AOR is committed to your privacy, your information will not be shared with any third party. You may unsubscribe at any time.
SPECIAL RETAILER OFFERS
JOIN US TODAY
For the latest:
AOR is committed to your privacy, your information will not be shared with any third party. You may unsubscribe at any time.
MONTHLY PRICE LIST
JOIN US TODAY
For the latest:
AOR is committed to your privacy, your information will not be shared with any third party. You may unsubscribe at any time.
PRODUCT LAUNCHES